Nonprofit Executive Search for Executive Directors, CEOs and Senior Leaders
Broadreach is a nonprofit executive search firm based in Marshfield, Massachusetts, on Boston’s South Shore. We place Executive Directors, CEOs, development leaders and senior finance, operations and program leaders for nonprofits across New England and nationwide.
Nonprofit leadership takes both a commitment to the mission and the business sense to run a complex organization. We look for both, along with the values and cultural fit that boards, staff and donors will notice from day one.
Nonprofit Leadership Roles We Fill
In practice, most of our nonprofit searches are for executive and senior leadership roles, including:
- Executive leadership: Executive Director, President and CEO
- Development: Chief Development Officer, VP of Development, Major Gifts leadership
- Operations: Chief Operating Officer, Director of Operations
- Programs: Chief Program Officer, VP of Programs
- Finance: Chief Financial Officer, Director of Finance
- Communications: Director of Communications and Marketing leadership
- Governance: Board recruitment and governance leadership
Types of Nonprofits We Serve
Specifically, we recruit for social and human service organizations, healthcare nonprofits, schools and educational institutions, foundations and advocacy groups, from community-based agencies to large multi-site organizations.
Nonprofit Executive Search in Boston and New England
Massachusetts is home to one of the country’s most active nonprofit sectors, from major foundations and health and education institutions to community agencies across the South Shore and beyond. Because our firm is based in Marshfield, MA, we know the regional leadership community. At the same time, we run searches nationwide.
How a Nonprofit Search Works
- Kickoff (week 1): First, we meet with the board chair or search committee to define the role, the must-haves and the compensation range.
- Market map (weeks 1–3): Next, we identify leaders at peer organizations and approach passive candidates directly and confidentially. That way, we don’t depend on job boards.
- Shortlist (typically 30–45 days): Then you meet a short, vetted slate. In addition, each candidate comes with our notes on experience, motivation and mission fit.
- Offer and onboarding: Finally, we manage references, the offer and the transition, and stay in touch through the first year.
In short, retained search suits Executive Director, CEO and confidential searches, while contingent search suits senior director roles when speed matters most.
Ready to hire your next nonprofit leader? Tell us about the role, and we’ll respond within one business day.
Frequently Asked Questions
What nonprofit leadership roles does Broadreach place?
Our searches cover Executive Directors, CEOs, and senior leaders in development, operations, programs, finance and communications, and we support board recruitment.
What types of nonprofits do you work with?
Social and human service organizations, healthcare nonprofits, schools and educational institutions, foundations and advocacy groups.
Do you recruit nonprofit executives in Boston and New England?
Yes. Since we’re based in Marshfield, MA, we recruit throughout Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, New Hampshire, Vermont and Maine, as well as nationwide.
How long does a nonprofit executive search take?
Most clients see a shortlist in 30–45 days. After that, total time to an accepted offer depends on the role, the board’s interview schedule and the candidate’s notice period.
Do you work with boards and search committees?
Yes. For Executive Director and CEO searches we typically work directly with the board chair or search committee throughout the process.
Do you offer retained or contingent search?
Both. Retained search suits Executive Director, CEO and confidential searches, whereas contingent search suits senior director roles where speed matters most.